First of all, I don't want to rate this with stars at all, but there is no option to bypass that rating. If the shoe fits, it's probably a 5-star shoe. If it doesn't, it's only a 1-star shoe. I'm only writing this to give feedback about fit. Personally, the shoes don't fit. It seems to me that Keens are getting narrower and narrower, and they don't fit me well anymore. Perhaps the wide sizes would, but they don't offer wide for styles that currently interest me. When I need to buy a safety toe, or a boot, I'll check back. The shoes themselves look good, and appear to be very well made which isn't a surprise; I've always had my Keens last a long time. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend them if the fit works for them.
Santa Cruz, CA