I really like this shoe a whole lot! I bought it because the guy in the store said people had told him they had this shoe for multiple years and loved it so much they were on there second, third pair etc. I have a pretty wide foot and I was finding everything I was looking at felt like my foot was on the edges of the outer rubber sole. These fit perfectly for me, and do not have the tight, cinching feeling a lot of leather type shoes give me. I have had them for about a year, and they still look almost brand new and feel just as good as day 1. When the time comes I'll buy another pair if they are still available. They have been good for my feet and I really like walking in them in the summer. They even look nice enough to wear out for the evening if your hike didn't get too messy. I have found zero odor held in the shoes either nor do my feet get very hot in these. The only thing I'd change is a slight improvement in grip for the icier conditions. Otherwise I highly recommend.
Jimmy the Canadian